Where overt arranged marriages still occur in Europe and the Americas it is usually within immigrant communities. The entire process of marriage is decided by the parents and the elders of the family. Most importantly, it is totally illogical for the government to intervene to stop people having the marriages that they and their family have chosen in the name of freedom of choice. If civil rights are being abused this needs to be resolved as soon as possible. In fact their cultural contributions are one of the most valuable additions to the societies in which they live. Where arranged marriage is truly traditional and not motivated at least in part by immigration it is equally traditional that brides leave home to go to their husband’s house. This page was last modified 12:18, 22 August 2011. More seriously, millions of people marry for the ‘wrong’ reasons: financial security, desire for children, parental pressure and lack of choice among potential partners. When marriages are arranged,many factors are taken into consideration before contemplating a match between two people,such as up-bringing, monetary equality, background, spiritual beliefs, and tradition and culture.Statistics show that these elements make the most satisfying and enduring relationships.Arranged marriage based on that gives couples a common ground of reference. For . Arranged marriage is a type of marital union where the bride and groom are primarily selected by individuals other than the couple themselves, particularly by family members such as the parents. We would love to hear what you think – please leave a comment! They are discrete social facts. In other works, whatever works. Finally, it is totally legitimate that husbands and wives should be able to choose the country where they have the best chances of making a good life to set up their homes, and this only serves to prove why brides from the third world might make the free choice to marry. Although we cannot intervene in countries that hold to such a value system, we can stop such a system being imported. In … If that version of theirs translates into an arranged marriage, well, let them try that out, why not? Absolutely not! The only exception to that statement would involve forced child marriages, which are exceptionally condemned by … The most convincing reason that proves arranged marriages is better than Love marriages would be Statistics! Furthermore, how can we possibly insist that immigrants respect our virtues of ‘toleration’ if that amounts to denying them cultural freedom? It is up to each person and family to decide what is the best course of action they should take. Illegal immigration: Does arranged marriage boost illegal immigration? Arranged marriages last longer than love marriages! The latter does not in any sense cause the former. Is History as a Subject in School Needed. The law can help children who are often seeking bargaining chips to help them evade the pressure to marry from their family and community. Often they are from far away from home, don’t speak the local language or dialect and are totally reliant on the husband’s house and family. We have made pathetically small progress in stamping out mail order brides which just goes to show how completely unenforceable a much more complex system of regulation over arranged marriages would be. That, of course, begs the question of what it is means for a marriage to “work”. Arranged marriage ensures a better and healthier upbringing of children as the arranged marriages are long-lasting and the risk of divorcing is eliminated, which has a good effect on the children, parents and extended family members makes sure that the children are being well-raised, as a result these children's development has been more fruitful as compared to children raised by just parents. 55% of all marriages in the world are arranged by parents and family, while in India this statistic goes as high as 88.4%. Maybe we should look harder at whether Pop stars marriages constitute ‘real’ marriages if we are about to make that distinction. For people who live in societies where arranged marriages are the practice, they are convinced that if they don’t feel any passionate love when the marriage takes place, love will bloom eventually. Arranged marriage is bad both for the individual women concerned and for women generally in society…. In fact, the author has belted out a 9 point rebuttal against arranged marriage. We attempt to challenge false marriages …. Every major religi…, Arranged marriage provides a cover for illegal immigration. Marriage is a concept of eternal curiosity. This doesn’t seem to oppress women. This only serves to illustrate that it is impossible to make any sensible division between what is and isn’t an arranged marriage and therefore quixotic to attempt a ban. 6. The bride and groom may have little say in the matter because their parents and extended relatives negotiate the relationship as if it were a business arrangement. It is more in the nature of a marriage between the families and not individuals. This is not acceptable within an egalitarian model of citizenship and does not fit with a western model of rights. Should the Cell Phones Be Allowed in Schools. The love marriage vs arranged marriage debate points to the changes in the way young people prefer to find their soulmate. But they both have certain pros and cons. The practice of arranged marriage separates communities, helping to stop integration and encourage distrust between communities. Christian, Jewish and Islamic leaders have all spoken out against gay marriage and point out that it runs counter to sacred writings. True multiculturalism itself relies on some basic shared value of commitment to a tolerant and fair society. Arranged marriages prevents people from marriages based solely on physical passion. Arranged marriages make up vastly the higher percentage in human history but have, largely in the last century, become unusual and morally questioned in the Western world. Debate Digest: Teacher-student friendships on Facebook, Law school, Balanced budget amendment, US debt ceiling deal. Arranged marriages in Europe and North America have idiosyncratically low levels of abuse and marital violence. It also helps to foster distrust in the wider community by holding to such a radically alien value, particularly where it is opposed to our notion of equal rights. Arranged marriage is a type of marriage which is arranged by parents or some elderly members of the family. This debate has been raging on ever since the idea of marrying for love has become a common practice in India. love marriage Vs arranged marriage debate in English - ndeed, whenever you talk about such topics, a lot of people will jump in the discussion. Should they be abolished, arranged marriages? Arranged marriages are very much ‘real’ marriages. The institution of marriage always creates interdependence and therefore scope for abuse and danger and the police and outsiders always find it more difficult to intervene where violence is within a marriage. Moreover, the line between what constitutes an arranged and what constitutes a forced marriage is so hazy it can’t be policed, as is the line between legitimate and illegitimate influence. In the latter case, arrangement commodifies women who are bartered between the male heads of houses. This is Season 1, Episode 1 of Arranged Marriage Problems - Solved. In my point of view arranged marriage is better than love marriage because the family taken the responsibility for arranged marriage. These arranged marriage pros and cons are just key points to consider. Arranged marriage is bad both for the individual women concerned and for women generally in society. Arranged marriages do involve choice. The best point of arranged marriage is the higher patience level and lower expectations. I’m against abolition, simply because I don’t see why someone else, whose views are different from mine, should not have the freedom to live out their version of what is right. Community integration: Does arranged marriage trap the community integration? This applies largely where it occurs among immigrant populations and helps to maintain a language barrier and an associated cultural ghettoisation. If not all, Indian women are socialised to accept marriage as their ultimate resort. It is vital to remember, however, that arranged marriage is not some kind of ‘us and them’ immigration issue. Arranging marriages is an insult to the very nature of marriage, which should be about creating a loving and lasting partnership and family. More important to remember is that these marriages last in exceptionally high numbers beyond the time required to receive a passport so they would be legitimate even in countries where marriages which are for the primary purpose of immigration are barred. Note to bloggers – Don’t write when … Many argue the right of gender equality and human rights. We attempt to challenge false marriages with non-nationals such as mail order brides for just this reason but are unable to properly examine most overtly arranged marriages because of the danger of being seen as culturally insensitive. Some couples will face compatibility issues. In some senses we can see the entire model of multiculturalism in the developed world reflected in this discussion of whether substantially different practices which maintain an ethnically individual community, drawing heavily on outside influences and immigration should be allowed. ), Stop forcing girl to marry someone or unon person. Further, the extent to which this is custom is a product of a patriarchal culture that oppresses women and an element of that culture which maintains the imbalance of power between the genders. It occurs both in religious communities and social groups within Western countries and the debate must reflect them as well. However, the majority of the issues with arranged marriages occur when the suitor (usually the girl) is … I personally don’t believe in love so I would do a arranged marriage as you wouldn’t love … While modern wisdom of the millennials finds itself more inclined towards love marriage, a significant chunk of marriageable individuals prefer going the good old arranged way. Arranged marriage is not a true ‘cultural value’ that is in some sense inviolate. Whether it’s an arranged marriage or a love marriage, the basic foundation of every marriage lies upon trust, understanding, equality, communication and a lot of love! With arranged marriage both individuals avoid courtship and dating. Who is going to stand up and tell ethnic minorities that they don’t know whether they want arranged marriages and whether or not it really is part of their culture? Arranged marriage provides a cover for illegal immigration, Australian article (critical of arranged marriage), Marriages and Families: Diversity and Change, http://www.dbp.idebate.org/en/index.php/Debate:_Arranged_marriage. The difference is merely that whole families are involved together in both considering the best options and in helping to achieve what is wanted. In arranged marriages - still practiced in Japan - the elders in a family look for a partner, seeking one of similar background, religion and ethnicity. 2. DebateWise. In some cultures a professional matchmaker may be used to find a spouse for a young person.. They want to venture out and find a nice person themselves. Well, this has been a topic of heated debate since decades. This is even more an issue where people come into a country where marriage is seen as a central value that should be free, where it is a specific challenge to any moral code. Quality of marriage: Is there real love existing in arranged marriages? As we have pointed out there is no conflict between arrangement and a guarantee of free choice, the two are entirely consistent. Should Smoking Be Banned in Public Places? (I say this eve as I myself am vehemently opposed to the idea of an arranged marriage, where I myself am concerned.